Let’s be frank.
For those of us who care about deforestation, the last few years have not been good.
The latest data tells us we’re losing more tropical tree cover than ever before. The biggest culprit is still commodity agriculture. And this is exactly what we, in the Tropical Forest Alliance, are working to deter.
Way back in 2012, the Alliance was founded to help the companies behind the Consumer Goods Forum (CGF) achieve their 2020 zero net deforestation target. And we were so committed to this collective goal, we even named ourselves TFA 2020.
For me, as the incoming TFA Director, it could be seen as something of a poison chalice.
What was I thinking? Taking the helm at a time when we seem destined to fall short of our founding principle? Tying myself to a target that is so short-term it will surely scare-off new partners?
Needless to say, I take a very different view.
Yes, the lagging indicators (which tell us what has happened) give real cause for concern. But the leading indicators (which point to what could happen) paint a brighter picture. And we know what more needs to be done to catalyse action and accelerate progress.
So, let me give you an alternative perspective.
If we only ever tell negative stories, we inhibit progress. Instead, let’s focus on the progress we did make in 2018, and look with optimism at priorities for 2019. And, for me, there are five BIG reasons to be positive:
- The market signals are getting stronger
Never underestimate the power of market forces, or the influence we have on them. I see an unstoppable movement towards sustainability. People demand it. Governments respond with new regulations. Markets respond by insisting on verified products. And pockets of bad practice are progressively squeezed out.
Yes, it’s a painfully slow process, but momentum is building. Many more players are signalling that deforestation must be removed from supply chains. And, in this regard, 2018 was an adrenalizing year.
One example among many is the Cerrado Manifesto from Brazil, which enable continued agricultural production in one of the world’s most productive landscapes while also seeking to protect important biodiversity. In 2018 the number of signatories for its Statement of Support leapt beyond 70 global brands. Meanwhile, government-backed initiatives like the Amsterdam Declaration grew in strength and the European Union announced its long-awaited roadmap to reduce deforestation.
As a producer, logic demands that you take note. If you can demonstrate your sustainability credentials, you can access any market in the world. If you can’t, your options become ever-more limited.
For 2019, the TFA will work to encourage more members of the CGF to commit and strengthen action seeing beyond 2020 and crucially we will broaden our attention to key players in the emerging economies. China alone accounts for 62% of the world’s soy imports, 32% of pulp and paper, and 11% of palm oil. As its economy prepares for the 2020 UN Biodiversity Summit, we have a great opportunity to increase engagement – which could make the signals deafeningly loud.
- It’s getting easier to distinguish the good from the bad
With improvements in monitoring comes greater transparency. You can more easily identify deforestation in supply chains. As a consequence, the pressure mounts for companies to report on their performance. And, again, we see real momentum.
One of 2018’s most significant announcements came from Wilmar, Asia’s leading agribusiness group, which committed to transparency across its entire supply chain. Meanwhile, the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), which unites 4,000 organisations globally, agreed a new certification standard to help distinguish the good from the bad.
For 2019, a priority is to build on this progress by supporting more robust monitoring tools which bring more certainty and granularity to better understand where commodities are still driving conversion. Their availability will, in turn, bring more pressure on more players to report on their performance – and provide more access to their data.
- More players are adopting holistic, landscape approaches
Increasingly, companies are looking beyond their immediate supply chains, and thinking about how they can contribute to the wider economic viability of farming and the rural economy. Related announcements from Unilever and Walmart, and also from the global agribusiness group Olam, were two highlights from 2018. We need more positive examples that showcase how production and protection can work hand in hand in tropical forest landscapes.
For 2019, we aim to focus our collective attention on 10-15 landscapes with strong jurisdictional leadership, where supply chain commitments can be complemented with other measures. And we will work with partners in each region to identify the most promising candidates.
- Innovative approaches to finance are enabling sustainable solutions to achieve scale
It would be naïve to overlook the role financing plays in agricultural decision-making. Farmers routinely seek third-party finance to fund their next crop, and the related credit terms generally determine what they grow – and how.
In the past we have seen plenty of small-scale, short-term finance initiatives directed at sustainable farming methods. But, in 2018, we saw the emergence of larger-scale, longer-term schemes, including one from Bunge and Santander in Brazil, which incentivises sustainable soybean production.
For 2019, we aim to catalyse the creation of more green finance mechanisms. For example, as finance ministries in tropical countries come to appreciate the true economic potential of a well-managed agricultural and forest sector, we expect more innovative schemes to emerge. And, as funds finally start to flow under REDD+ schemes, there is definite potential for mechanisms that incorporate carbon finance.
5. More people are waking-up to the role of forests in addressing global warming
For many years, forests had been largely absent from the climate change debate. Yet they are the planet’s single most powerful mechanism for sequestering carbon (or, conversely, releasing it into the atmosphere).
In 2018, the tenor of the debate changed. For example, the IPCC 1.5°C Special Report made it clear that, to address climate change, more forests must be protected and restored. Forests also house more than 80% of the world’s terrestrial biodiversity so are front and centre of the renewed global effort for a New Deal for Nature and People.
For 2019, we all need to push forests and deforestation to the very centre of the climate, biodiversity and food debates.
Turning the tide of deforestation
But let’s not dwell on it. Obsessing over the merits of an eight-year-old target doesn’t just tie us to an arbitrary moment in time, it also puts a finite limit on our aspirations. Instead, let’s focus on the way forward.
Given everything we have learnt and the progress we are seeing, I am convinced the trajectory can be bent. When that happens, even more pressure will be placed on the many laggards in our community, and more encouragement will be handed to the pace-setters. We will then enter a scenario when, instead of simply putting an end to deforestation, we have a chance to improve and restore many of our degraded landscapes.
The Tropical Forest Alliance was set up to advance public-private partnership in the tropical forest space. We stand ready to up our game and support our partners to deliver on the promise of eliminating and, ultimately, reversing deforestation.
By Justin Adams, Director, Tropical Forest Alliance
This Op-Ed was first published by GreenBiz and the World Economic Forum.